Want to read more? Join my Patreon community

On being a marks fetishist

Posted at 22:38 on 7 Jul 2013 by Pandora / Blake

Tags: dominance and submission, kink

When I was at Boardwalk Badness Weekend, I told my roommate Jade that I was a "marks fetishist". I didn't think much about this wording at the time, but apparently it intrigued her, and she asked me to expand on it.

What I like about them

What I mean by saying I'm a marks fetishist is, perhaps, obvious, as I can express it in the wording of Jade's questions: I treasure marks. The marks I get (or give) are part of my kink, and have some deeper meaning. I desire them, negotiate for scenes that will cause them, and sometimes feel disappointed if you dont get them. Marks are arousing to me; they are a badge of honour. I fuss over them, look at them in the mirror, take pictures of them.

In this post when I talk about "marks" I mostly mean the marks that are left on a bottom from a spanking, beating or whipping. I have had, and enjoyed, other types of mark - from rope, teeth, nails - on other parts of my body, but I don't seek them out or obsess over them in quite the same way.

Marks, for me, are a gift from someone I love, a memento of a beautiful scene, a keepsake to be treasured. They are a badge of honour; hard won and well deserved. (In Atlantic City I deliberately engineered a cold caning scene with Mr Allen with the aim of creating beautiful marks. I'm planning to write about that scene for the next Kink of the Week, which serendipitously is "canes".) I love being marked; I love the drama of it, the aesthetics of it, the way they serve as a visual journal of memorable, intense scenes.

During a submissive scene it's often hard to retain accurate memories of what takes place, and sometimes you might enter a sort of altered state of consciousness where are you aren't clearly aware of what's happening, even at the time. Pain is fleeting, and as anyone who has ever fantasised about a spanking knows, it is very hard to remember what it's like when it's not actually happening. Marks are a lasting, visual reminder of experiences that can be dreamlike and confused.

Marks are also associated with severity, which is another kink of mine. I am an exhibitionist, and severity is much more satisfying for me if it's witnessed or recorded. Filming, photographing and writing about a scene are all ways of doing that, and that's why I have a blog and a spanking porn site. But marks are another testament, another record, of an intense play experience, and they are equally important to me.

This is from a journal entry I wrote in 2004, when I was relatively new to kinky exploration and enjoying the honeymoon period of my first dom/sub relationship with Tom:

My body is a map of marks, the signatures left on me by each encounter. You can read it, if you know the code. It is a record in four dimensions, that fades and alters over time, affected by the passing of days - and by the layering of new marks on top of old. It is an art form; the old cliché about the body being a canvas. Afterwards, alone again, I cannot resist inspecting them, twisting round in the bathroom to catch a glimpse in the mirror, watching with fascination as they change colour, slowly heal. Sometimes I awake in the mornings and whole areas of colour have gone completely; the superficial marks, the pink and the red, are absorbed by sleep, leaving no testament to the damage done the night before. On other occasions a beating I did not consider to have been so terribly bad will linger in my muscles for weeks, painless, after a while, but persistently visible.

Practical considerations

Since I started keeping this blog, my life hasn't given me many opportunities to be marked. If you regularly need a fresh, unmarked bottom for spanking film shoots or nude photoshoots, you have to restrict your play accordingly. When I first started spanking modelling I wrote about the problem of bruising. But one's bottom becomes resilient over time, and these days I have to go out of my way to get satisfyingly lasting marks. Those days of a moderate play session leaving marks that lasted two weeks or more are long behind me, and at a personal level, I miss it. But professionally speaking, it's hugely convenient not being a "magic marker" any more; I can book shoots and sessions without worrying about it unless I'm planning severe scenes, or playing several days in a row. (For instance, I'm currently producing a week-long Dreams of Spanking shoot in September, and anticipating how marked my bottom will be at the end of each day is proving a significant factor in my scheduling.) I spent a couple of years feeling disappointed whenever a good scene didn't mark, but now I've come to expect it; these days, if I wasn't going out looking for it, I'm surprised when I mark.

Emotional reminders

As I write this, Ihave a couple of faint cane stripes on my bottom, and I honestly don't know whether they're from my birthday caning a week last Friday, or the switch session I played on Monday. Does it matter? Actually, yes, it does. If I know the marks are from my birthday caning, a memorable, sexy, and unexpected scene with my much-loved D, I will treasure them much more than if they were from a professional engagement. Since I can't be sure, I'm ambivalent about these particular marks. But when I do know the origins, it's a strong emotional factor.

The flipside of the way that marks can be an affirming, joy-inducing reminder of a positive experience is that they can be a jarring reminder of a traumatic or negative one. The marks from a bad scene are a stain, a taint; if the marks were caused by something you did not consent to, or in a way you did not consent to, then the marks themselves become an extension of that lack of consent, an unwanted intrusion into the sanctity of your body. The emotional upheaval of a bad scene will take longer to fade if you have to wait for marks to disappear before you can start to put it behind you. Luckily I've only experienced this once or twice in my life, and I have learned to mediate my stress about it and not let unwanted marks ruin my week, but there is still a strong emotional response that needs to be managed. Marks can extend or aggravate a traumatic experience, and can be a reminder of unpleasant experiences as well as positive ones - at least until they heal and fade. The silver lining is that when they do fade, this can be a good emotional cue for emotional healing as well.

Marks are capricious. They seem to always last either too long or not long enough. They often refuse to arise from the emotionally intense, intimate, personal scenes of which I crave mementoes; and they have a persistent tendency to arise from professional encounters which I wasn't particularly invested in. I mark less as time goes by, but I still find my marking difficult to predict. Whether I mark or not often seems to depend on unknown factors, impossible to control.

Limits and control

Despite this, controlling marks is something I have spent many years trying to do. When I play a professional or personal scene I'm always aware of whether it is marking me, or likely to mark. If I have work coming up that I have to be unmarked for, lasting marks become a hard limit. The only truly bad spanking shoot I've ever had (in 2008, with a company that doesn't shoot much any more - if you're a model who wants to know the company's name, email me) was arranged at short notice, where I negotiated beforehand that I needed to be unmarked for a prior booking a few days later; this limit was ignored.

Thankfully, I haven't had someone deliberately break that limit in personal play, although I have had personal scenes that left longer lasting marks than I or my top anticipated, resulting in my having to cancel or rebook shoots. Over the years I have learned to err on the side of caution, and have often wished I could play harder at home, and felt frustrated at having to hold back to save my skin. It's an irony that personal scenes are the ones I am more likely to desire or treasure marks from, and the least likely, for practical reasons, to result in them. I can justify being marked from paid, pre-arranged work more easily, but this is less likely to have deeper personal meaning.

One consequence of this conflict of interest is that in a personal scene I am often hyper-aware of whether I am marking, or likely to mark, and if I let myself start to worry that my top is not being as observant as I need them to be, this can ruin my immersion in a scene and stop me from relaxing into a submissive headspace.

From the top perspective

As a professional top, I deal with marking as a limit all the time. Many of the people I play with have lifestyles that are incompatible with marking, and marking is always one of the first things I negotiate. Like me, playmates often want to play harder than is practical, and so the game is often to play as hard as possible within their marking limits. It's not unusual for me to be given fairly specific time limits - e.g. "no marks that will last more than 24 hours", "no marks that will last more than 3 days". I have learned, and am still learning, to judge those limits as accurately as possible, and of course it varies hugely from bottom to bottom.

One of my great pleasures is a submissive client who is new to playing, marks with that beautiful, dramatic ease, and desires and enjoys being marked as much as I do. I love playing with newbies not only because it is an honour to give someone a safe and positive first experience, but because I take such a personal, aesthetic, sadistic enjoyment in watching the marks blossom on their skin. It's fascinating to see cane stripes which would be a mild pink on me bloom vivid red and purple on them.

So yes, I also have a marks fetish as a top and sadist. It's instant gratification at its finest; every act has immediate visible consequences. I become the artist, painting my subject's flesh with pain. I take pride in my handiwork, enjoying it when I achieve exactly the visual effect I was aiming for, and admiring a set of perfectly parallel, symmetrical stripes.

I love it when I am specifically asked for a scene that will leave dramatic marks. Our mutual enjoyment feeds into each other, with my admiring comments about the state of their bottom adding to their excitement, and ending with both of us geeking delightedly over their welts in front of a mirror, commenting on all the finer details, and documenting it obsessively with photos. Clients and I can email back and forth discussing photographs of their marked bums for weeks. I love providing this experience for likeminded playmates because I empathise with it; I feel the same way when it's me on the receiving end.

Technical details

Of course, creating a satisfying set of marks can be a challenge. You'll read more about this from the sub perspective when I write about the caning I received from Mr Allen, but from the dom side it can be a fascinating test of skill, especially when playing with experienced, hardened players who don't mark easily. I love exploring and refining my understanding of the finer technical details of how to generate different kinds of mark. And of course, other players dislike marks, or prefer to avoid them, and I have to tailor the scene accordingly.

There are ways to control marking. Different implements have different effects, of course, as do different severity levels, and even using implements in different orders. Narrow, heavy implements, such as canes, whips and riding crops used firmly, leave vivid skin welts and can be sharp enough to break the skin. Narrow, light implements, such as quirts and martinets, leave raised weals, and very thin implements such as switches and birches can break the skin despite not being very heavy. Broad, heavy implements like straps or paddles don't raise weals, but over long or consecutive scenes they do leave bruises. Belts can fit into either category depending on how broad they are, but when folded they tend to be heavy enough to bruise. Canes and crops can bruise as well, if they are dense enough.

The way to emphasise marking is to use these sharper implements "cold" - that is, hard, without any other play beforehand to prepare or warm the skin. The harder the first strokes on unprepared skin, the more dramatic the marks will be. The way to decrease or avoid marking is to warm the skin as slowly and thoroughly as possible, starting with gentle hand spanking, moving onto harder hand spanking, then leather, allowing time for endorphin release, gradually preparing the skin for what will follow. Warm-ups are a kindness in professional work not only for the comfort of the spankee, but because they reduce marking. Of course this only goes so far - a sufficiently hard caning will break the skin no matter how warmed up you are (as Jade herself discovered in Atlantic City). Bizarrely, warm-downs work too - a hand spanking after a caning can help not onto bring your sub gently back to earth, but it also dissipates the collected blood beneath the skin, and helps the marks heal faster. You can break up bruises the same way, too, with hand spanking and massage.

If you want to reduce marking and speed healing, keeping the bottom supple and moisturised is the most important thing. I use Vitamin E cream in general, and aloe vera gel on severe welts while they're fresh, but shea butter and cocoa butter are rated highly too. Arnica doesn't have any provable effect, whether as tablets or cream; I've heard a lot of anecdotal reports of its efficacy and used to think it helped me, but I don't bother with it any more. Here's a more detailed post on caring for your bottom after a severe scene.

Creating and controlling marks is an art, and I suspect I'll never stop learning. I love hearing ideas and stories about how to manage marking, and learning from more experienced players.

Alpha and omega

Over the course of your kinky life, marking comes full circle. New players experience startlingly vivid, dramatic marks from moderate play. Experienced players find their bottoms mark less easily over time. But if you don't let your bottom fully heal between scenes, or simply as you mature and grow old, your skin becomes more fragile, and breaks more easily. I have played with delightful septuagenarians who adore hard play, but are frustrated by how easily they seem to bleed. To maintain your bottom's resilience as long as possible, let any marks heal fully before playing again; moisturise regularly; and if you start to notice hard spots that won't heal, or weak spots that bleed easily, take a break from playing for a few months until your skin recovers.

So far I've managed to avoid having to take this sort of break. I say that I miss the days when I marked easily, but twelve months off from spanking is probably all I would need to return my bottom to a freshly virginal, markable state. But as long as I can avoid any long term damage, I have no desire to make that sacrifice.

Marks fetishist I may be, but at this point in my life my spanking fetish, it seems, trumps it: I'd rather a year of spanking without marks than a year of no spanking for the sake of better ones.


[...] On being a marks fetishist: “Marks are capricious. They seem to always last either too long or not long enough. They often refuse to arise from the emotionally intense, intimate, personal scenes of which I crave mementoes; and they have a persistent tendency to arise from professional encounters which I wasn’t particularly invested in.” (Pandora Blake) [...]

you don't want to have to explain marks from a spanking. Sex should be discussed...will it be part of the scene? If so, safer sex needs to be discussed? Roles should be discussed, whether or not they will be acted out. Even who is top and who is bottom, in some cases. Related activities should be discussed...will bondage be included? humiliation? Physical limits are an important discussion. Heart problems, back problems..those apply to both top and bottom! Does the bottom bruise easily, do they have breathing difficulty, any circulation problems? Emotional limits need to be discussed - was there any abuse or assault in the bottom's past? Any known triggers to prevent (or deliberately lead to) that catharsis we talked about?

Thanks - a great treatise on the enduring appeal of marks!

Admittedly not everyone’s fetish, but some of us, while displaying absolutely no other narcissistic traits, really do engage with our marks - both as a badge of honour (“A caning’s not a caning without a thorough marking….”) and for their aesthetic and emotional appeal – a step towards the branding / body modification culture but without the permanency. As you say, marks are quixotic, which is why it’s so exciting to track their progress as they rapidly wax then so slowly wane (including those occasional strange ones that appear out of nowhere with no concrete recollection of their origin). A mirror and a camera are indeed a bottom’s best friend! Is part of the intrigue that the bottom is hidden from one’s gaze so we must make special efforts to observe our marks? (I once took a fairly severe hand tawseing, to see what the hype was all about. Fascinating to watch the wrist grow purple and swollen over the next few days, butnthis didn’t have the same deep attachment as bottom marks.)

I wonder, did the warriors of old take such pride in their battle scars? I suspect they did.

It’s many years since I did the ‘emotional piece’ in s/m play but, yes, I well remember the sense of the marks being a ‘shared creation’, with the marker taking almost as much interest in their progression as the markee. Perhaps a similar ‘common bond’ to that experienced by the artist and the model (and viewing the marks as a form of body art almost takes us full circle….)?

One of life’s lesser tragedies is that these hard-earned marks we treasure so deeply are so tricky to share with others! Just sometimes, almost subconsciously, they find an excuse for a popping out for a brief airing – the glutes stretch in the gym shorts, or the vanilla slideshow on the camera to friends which accidentally scrolls back just one frame too far! A natural human desire to want to share that which we’re proud of?

It was also a little sad that, in the distant days when domestic / school CP was not unheard of, the withering threat was always “You won’t be sitting down for a week!” and not “Your bottom’ll be well marked for a week!” Why did they emphasise the negative rather than the positive?

And to address the problem of a bottom that no longer marks to its owner’s satisfaction, there’s several other fleshy areas on the human body almost crying out for their inaugural marking……(with a sensible implement, of course). A minority of bottoms may exhibit a desire to raise the bar, seeking ever ‘better’ marks at each play. Probably it helps that this is a mutual activity so the responsible top can exercise due restraint.

Your final points are well made – almost a quality v. quantity dilemma. But could you really survive a year without spanking – I mean, what would you write about!?

Wow, finally had some time to read this. So so glad I did - and thank you so much for writing it!

First of all: HAPPY BELATED BIRTHDAY, my dear friend!!!! I'm sorry I didn't realize it. I hope it was fun (and am going to check back here to see if you wrote about it.)

Secondly...you are such an incredible wealth of knowledge! No wonder my caning scene with you was so very perfect. You really know your stuff, woman!

I was particularly interested in the part about playing as a Top, and having to know how NOT to leave marks, or to leave ones that only last a specified time. I can't imagine how one would know that...obviously takes a whole lot of observation and experience.

But my favorite part is when you talk about your emotional connection to your marks. It makes me sad to think about the conflict inherent in loving them to come from personal play (and wanting to play hard enough to get them) and yet not being able to, so that the result is that the marks you end up getting are from your professional work. Now I think I truly understand why you were upset that day at BBW.

Thank you so SO much for sharing this.


Wow, Pandora, I've found your post on marks really liberating - I could almost have written it myself; you express openly and beautifully the fetish I have not dared to talk about to anyone. Thank you. I was never caned at school, and have craved those lovely marks on my bottom ever since. I am disappointed with most spanking material, which seems to be mainly about pain - and nothing about the beauty and pride in those marks. Now that I am well past my youth, even middle age, it is probably too late for me to work out that fetish with safety, but your blog has at least set me free to enjoy it in my imagination with even greater pleasure. Thank you.

my love of marks

I have always relished the marks I got from canings which is by far my favorite punishment instrument. I can honestly say that the marks arouse me and to touch or see them brings on an erection that will not just go away on its own. So I must be a marks fetishist too.

I don't know if it's just me or if perhaps everybody else experiencing issues with your website.
It appears as if some of the text within your posts are running off the screen. Can someone else please comment and let me know if this is happening to
them as well? This might be a problem with my browser because I've had
this happen previously. Thanks

Hello very cool blog!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Amazing ..

I will bookmark your site and take the feeds additionally?
I'm satisfied to search out numerous useful info here within the publish, we'd like work out extra techniques on this regard, thanks for sharing.
. . . . .

Aw, this was a really good post. Spending some time and actual effort
to produce a good article… but what can I say… I put things off a lot and never seem to
get nearly anything done.

First off I would like to say terrific blog!
I had a quick question that I'd like to ask if you do not mind.

I was curious to find out how you center yourself and clear your thoughts prior to writing.
I have had a hard time clearing my thoughts in getting my ideas
out there. I do take pleasure in writing however
it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes tend to
be wasted just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or hints?
Many thanks!

Please let me know if you're looking for a author for your blog.
You have some really great posts and I think I would be a good asset.
If you ever want to take some of the load off, I'd really like to write some content for your blog in exchange for a link back
to mine. Please blast me an email if interested.

It's an awesome paragraph designed for all the web viewers

This article offers clear idea in support of the new
people of blogging, that genuinely how to do blogging
and site-building.

Add your comment:

Post as:

(or log in to post with your own username)



Want to read more? Join my Patreon community
Become a Patron!

Find Pandora online

Feminist porn

Spanking porn

Spanking blogs

Sex and Politics blogs

Toplists & directories